Monday, November 5, 2007

Everyone Needs a George (or Two)

There are a couple of pocket doors in our house stuck from day one. Dysfunctional, you might say. We have entertained several theories about why they don't work. One was that they had fallen off their tracks. With that theory in place, we tried with a crowbar to raise them back into position. Didn't work. Bad theory, no solution.

Neither of us has a passion (nor an aptitude, obviously) for household fix-it projects. So the pocket door issue languished unresolved in the "not important/not urgent" category. That is, until we were two days away from having a houseful of guests.

Of course we've had housefuls of company before, but there were always some family members in the mix. So we did what you do with family: we stuck them in the dysfunctional room with the door that won't close and the closet that won't open. When they complained, we just said, "tough."

But now we were faced with house guests who were, well, "bona-fide." The pocket door issue became both important and urgent! There was only one thing to do. We had to call George.

George happens to be competent in several (hundred) areas we are clueless about. While we had wasted precious hours trying to diagnose the doors, George looked at them with expert eyes. He examined them from a few angles. He rubbed his chin. He said "hmmm" about three times. "These doors are too long," he declared. In fifteen minutes he had them shaved, reinstalled and working just fine.

Andrew Keen wrote a provocative book in which he laments the demise of our faith in the expert. He holds the Internet responsible. It has become way too easy for us to Google or Wiki something and think we've become instant experts. Everybody thinks they know everything.

I don't deny that there's plenty of information (some of it even accurate) available with just a click. But does it make any sense to think we are completely competent to synthesize, interpret and act on information in subject areas we have not taken the time to study in depth?

Experts see things we don't see. Experts see things differently. Experts carry tools we don't possess.

The smartest, most successful people are not people who know everything. Rather, they are people who can distinguish between their areas expertise and their areas of rank amateurism. To handle the latter, they hire the experts.

If you think you may have fallen off the wagon and become addicted to the idea that you know everything, I have the Three Step Progam for you.
  1. Acknowledge that you have a pocket door problem.
  2. Admit your powerlessness over the pocket door problem.
  3. Call George.

Copyright starfishdoc 2007

4 comments:

Unknown said...

You got me! Although I don’t claim to be an exert at everything I do my fair share of scouring the internet for information (especially health related!) and then relaying it in sentence usually beginning with "I read this information on WebMD" and "According to WebMD my symptoms point to X". Sometimes, err... most of the time, I get carried away and realize this when my girlfriend starts to chuckle at my pronouncements. At this point I pick up the phone and call the DR. :)

We all sometimes need a little help recognizing our amateurism (and maybe some one to chuckle at our ridiculousness).

Starfishdoc said...

Dear Miss Catherine (akaTFG),
I hardly know what to say in response to your poignant, honest confession! You give the perfect example of web-gone-wrong activity. Thank you so much for sharing this with SMS readers. So glad you're part of the sanity team!Thank goodness for that girlfriend of yours!

Adam said...

Hallelujah! No more sleeping in the room with no door. You just think those were bona fide guests. Actually, they were scouts sent by me on a Pre-Thanksgiving reconnaissance mission.

Starfishdoc said...

Ciao Ado,
Comme va? I thought they looked a bit suspicious!